June 21, 2017
June 17, 2017
It's not unusual for us to receive numerous emails each week asking if we still offer upgraded crossovers for JV60. This is one that we built yesterday:
These are hand made with quality parts and the modifications I used as a JV60 owner. The mods were make or break in my case, resulting in keeping my JV60 speakers for many years. I actually found the sound to be more enjoyable than many high end speakers, priced well above $10k. The sound is smoother and more refined.
We actually offer crossover upgrades for any speaker. This includes:
We actually offer crossover upgrades for any speaker. This includes:
- Hand built crossovers using the same design but upgraded parts
- Design mods to adjust the sound to your preferences
- Modified designs to suit new drivers
- Custom crossovers for custom speakers
June 13, 2017
In most cases, our services are engaged after a client has already purchased acoustic treatment. Very often we are called in when there is a specific and objectionable problem they were not able to solve with generic and free advice on the internet. Here we started working with the client before the studio was built and so this meant we could ensure a great result right from the start.
Most bass traps on the market are best described as "low midrange" absorbers. Their effectiveness is typically very limited. Here we built custom bass traps, running floor to ceiling. The traps are 340mm deep and 1000mm wide. One in each corner.
The bass traps are resistive and operate deliberately into the mid and treble regions. The advantage here is that they serve a dual function and actually reduce the amount of midrange absorbers that would otherwise be required. The traps were built as 8 modules, which were then bolted together once delivered onsite. A further advantage of the large depth is that they are more stable. These traps were made with Polymax XHD which we also sell as raw panels for DIYers.
Vicoustic Wavewood panels are mounted either side of the rear corner bass traps. This space is also a band practise space. It was important to create a neutral sounding room which was not overly dead. Part of creating this balance was mixing diffusion and absorption.
Vicoustic Multifusors are installed on the ceiling. These are very cost-effective panels and we like how easy they are to install. Being a light weight polystyrene panel, they can be installed with self adhesive picture hanging strips. It's an easy DIY install, which avoids the extra cost of a professional install job.
It was actually this product that first prompted us to become a Vicoustic dealer - it was clear that many of our clients needed an easy to install low cost diffusor.
SVS SB1000 subwoofer set up under the mixing desk. We consider this sub to be a value leader. It's a capable sub with very good performance for the price of a raw driver and amp. Many studios install a cheapie sub and most of them are simply not worth using. The temptation is often there to buy a sub in the $500 - 700 price range. These can only be considered "junk subs." It's a very good idea to spend just a little more for a sub that is far superior. We provided the sub along with calibration. We tested every feasible sub location, finally opting for the most practical placement with the best performance. Here a nearfield location worked best.
Very often the placement of the monitors and their relationship with their surrounds can create issues. A very accurate monitor is easily undermined with poor setup and a hit and miss approach. We worked through various options with placement to determine the optimal setup.
Products and services included here:
- Consultation on design and layout of the space prior to construction
- Acoustic treatment design
- Custom acoustic treatment
- SVS sub
- Sub integration
- Audio calibration
June 4, 2017
This is a speaker we've wanted to create for some time. Perhaps our most versatile ever. We wanted to create a compact point source speaker. It would cater to some unique situations:
- nearfield monitors
- a small room where a deeply involving sound stage is desired
- valve and lower powered amplifiers
- a centre channel speaker that can be placed on its side
- a surround speaker with equal horizontal and vertical dispersion to serve more than one row of seats
- a premium Atmos ceiling surround speaker (which doesn't measure so badly the response plot has to be hidden)
These are quite diverse situations but all of them benefit greatly from a point source speaker. We decided to commence working on this project and the first step was finding the right driver.
One promising driver was the Eminence Beta8CX. The parameters were quite useful and initially it seemed quite appealing that any compression driver with a thread could be tested. We're quite fussy on which compression driver we use as they are very often make or break with HE designs. Price was also an attractive feature. We know that people don't tend to spend big on surround speakers, so this was a key issue.
The Eminence driver has useful sensitivity and works well in a reasonably compact enclosure. However, when we tested various compression drivers, we noticed a serious problem.
There is a broad 15 dB valley from 4 - 11k. We tried various compression drivers but all exhibited a similar problem. Even with the benefit of a DSP active crossover, the sonic result was poor. One of our requirements was the ability to use a passive crossover, where we don't have the option to simply add EQ to a valley this large.
A further challenge with coaxial drivers is that they tend to be expensive. Money does not necessarily buy you exceptional performance. The reality is the coaxial drivers are difficult to get right.
Here is an example of one of the better units:
This woofer is mounted in a different enclosure so it's not directly comparable in all respects, however, the far superior response in the treble region is clear. Despite being one of the best, we can still see some obvious problems. Numerous dips in the woofer response above 1k where we are likely to want to cross to the tweeter. A peak just above 4k which is very audible. We can also see that the compression driver has very limited bottom end response.
The Game changer
Here we have a driver that changes the game. Without this driver, this project would not get off the ground.
In contrast to the cheaper stamped steel frame of the Eminence, we have a very solid cast frame. There is no dust cap here. An accordion cloth surround ensures very long life and very control of the cone edges.
The compression driver is integral to the design. Shown above is the back of the phase plug and you may also notice the copper shorting ring. This arrangement provides much better alignment of the acoustic centres.
Here we can see the best of both previous drivers. The woofer has a well behaved response, free from the problemmatic dips and breakup of the pro coax. We also have a very nicely extended top end without a falling response that needs to be corrected - this makes for a simpler crossover. Overall, a much more usable driver. Our first trial with a very crude crossover revealed a musical result - this is a very good sign.
As our long time blog readers will know, we've held Rythmik subs in high esteem for a long time. We first experience them back in 2006 and it was clear from the first moment they were fired up that these are articulate subs. The very clean and dry bass sound was clear even before they had been calibrated correctly. We are now Australian dealers for Rythmik subs. We offer their full range of kits and we also custom build finished subs, adding Australian-made enclosures to Rythmik kits.
Rythmik kits include the driver and servo enabled amplifier. Both are integral to the design and sold together only.
We also offer flat packs, which are CNC machined to fit together and make for an easier build. These start at $399. Our standard designs are modestly sized 12" and 15" sealed subs, however, we can also create custom flat packs to suit any project.
We can offer:
- open baffle
Custom made subs in Australia
We manufacture subs in Australia based on the Rythmik kits.
This is one of our 15" subs (sealed). Neo magnets are concealed within the enclosure - they serve to attach the grille without unsightly old clips.
Featured here is a custom sub with dual 12" drivers, serving to reduce vibration. The client wanted a perspex cover instead of a conventional grille. Designed to match the existing entertainment cabinet in solid teak.
June 2, 2017
A client approached us to help upgrade their music system. This application was unique because the system would be connected to a digital keyboard. It could be argued that they wanted to create a live music experience at home, literally. Initially the interest was surrounding an accurate custom sub. However, when we heard about the monitors they would be using, the conversation changed. They were intending to purchase some monitors we had worked with before. We do come across quite a range of studio monitors in our consulting work. We proposed an alternative custom monitor and the result is seen here.
First we start with an Air Motion tweeter. Well regarded by many for their transparency and air. Of course, a tweeter with "air" in it's name must have air! And it must have motion, or it won't tweet very well. Bad attempts at humour aside, these are tweeters we don't normally use. One of the reasons is that many of them don't suit our designs. Another is that the response is often not as smooth as we'd like. However, in this case, we are using an active crossover which can overcome this aspect. Here we offered a choice between a silk dome and an air motion - they chose the latter.
Also important here is the ability to achieve reasonable bass extension in a sealed enclosure - adequate to cross to a sub. Often our goals would suggest a 4" or 5" mid but the bass requirements suggested a larger woofer.
We also liked the open basket design, which is ideal in terms of avoiding any coloration.
Low diffraction design
Given the intended use as a nearfield monitor, we considered that baffle edge diffraction on axis is actually more important than usual. We can easily see diffraction effects in our testing and crossover development, but in a typical real world situation, much of what we see becomes swamped by the room effects. In a nearfield situation, what we measure in our testing is closer to what the listener experiences. Room effects are more subtle.
In order to minimise diffraction, we did two things. Firstly, we carefully placed each driver with offsets optimised to tame the impact of diffraction on frequency response. Secondly, the baffle edges are rounded, which is especially important when using a small tweeter without any loading from a waveguide.
Again we've removed the round overs and shown the impact of tweeter position only. We've now moved the tweeter into its final position.
Here we can see that now adding the round over further improves the smoothness (red).
Now with the woofer, we compare the impact of the roundovers with the woofer (below). As you can see, the roundover has less effect than with the tweeter.
We have little choice with placement of the woofer but some adjustment is still beneficial.
The black line shows how the final position compares to the middle of the box. There is not a great deal of difference but if we did have a crossover near 2k, we might be facing a challenge.
Now we've added the impact of the roundover and we can now see that it benefits us more than when placed in the centre. The dip around 2k is reduced, although the effect is subtle.
The enclosure we used here is a braced 32mm MDF with separate sealed chamber for the tweeter and DSP amplifier. The walls are internally lined with 15mm rubber sheets. The result is when knocked, it's like knocking on a concrete column. The cabinet is internally filled with acoustic material.
Here we can see the raw farfield frequency response. In this measurement, the drivers are simply mounted in the enclosure and then tested with no DSP filters in place. We did test with a cap on the tweeter, so its low end roll off has been modified.
We see a gentle hump around 1k which is also seen in the datasheet. The woofer peak at 4.3k is related to the driver itself and is also seen in the data sheet. The smaller ripples in the woofer response are +/- 1 dB excluding the general trend.
The tweeter exhibits a rising response. This may be behind many of the subjective comments about these tweeters when this isn't corrected. In comparing it to other tweeters, we did notice what sounded like greater deal but also a thin sounding bottom end. This measurement explains what we heard.
Here we used a MiniDSP ICE amplifier with two channels for each speaker. The DSP crossover allows for very precise control.
One of the things we like about DSP active crossovers is the precision with which we can control the response. Although passive crossovers can be quite sophisticated, we find there are limits to what we can achieve, at times with a difficult compromise between response shaping and part count. With a DSP crossover, we typically have more filters than any design is likely to need.
Here we have now achieved a response of +/- 2 dB.
We also evaluated various settings to adjust the tweeter level. In this case, we found that a near flat treble response produced the best results and the most balanced sound.
One the crossover design work was complete, the original character of the tweeter changed significantly. The exaggerated top end detail and thin sound was replaced with a very balanced sound. Still, there was no question that its detail was very appealing.